Ed wrote:
It amuses me when I read about how the rattlesnake wants to avoid you. I've encountered many who have a 'stand your ground' philosophy. And I always seem about to step on one before I hear or see it.
That's my experience as well. I imagine this may ignite a whirlwind of politically correct responses, but if we actually reduced the number of rattlers (yep, i mean killin' 'em) and other snakes took their ecological place, why would that be so bad?
Before anyone responds, we're trying very enthusiastically to eradicate polio. That means we're killing each and every polio virus we encounter, with the hope of making them extinct during our lifetimes...how is that different? They don't know what they're doing, but they quite innocently kill us. So we kill them instead. Good choice. What makes rattlers so much more valuable than another living creature like a virus? Or your dog? Or you?
People hunted grizzlies until they were extinct in CA. So we can hike without the fatalities that they suffer in Alaska and Canada. True, there aren't many, but if that fatality were, say, your child, would you say it is just a sacrifice we have to make? That they were here first? Or that your child had no right to go into the wilderness, so it served them right for displaying such hubris?
I have yet to hear a clear, reasonable argument that we shouldn't do everything we can to eradicate rattlers and encourage other native species to replace them in their ecological role. They are aggressive, dangerous creatures that cause untold expense and suffering for about 8000 people each year in the US alone, with about 2400 of those victims suffering permanent damage to the tissue involved. That means you permanently lose function of that foot, or ankle, or hand...
Most of those people are avid outdoors people, like the people on this board. No, they're not all drunk hillbillies who have no better sense than to pick up an angry rattler.
So, what's wrong with those rattlesnake roundups? Personally, I'm not sure they're a bad idea. If there were a certain group of people that tried to kill 8000 people a year, wouldn't we want them removed? Just like a virus? What makes snakes so special? Even if most people live, ending up with a lame limb and $143,000 in debt are reason enough to me to remove the threat. How is that so wrong? Just a question.
z