Hikin_Jim wrote:I don't normally like heavy leather boots with big lug soles, but I was glad that I had them yesterday. One of my friends who just had walking shoes was really slipping and sliding whereas I was fine.
I am amazed at the number of people I see trekking in the snow in low-cut hiking shoes. A few with confidence, tripping alone like fairies, but it is not for me. Even ankle-high boots with good lug soles are often not enough, in my opinion. Admittedly, I am now an ox-footed klutz, but I had the same opinion when I was a seasoned snow climber. I was more comfortable high on Shasta with crampons on my feet and an ice axe in my hand, than I often was walking a Southern California trail in the snow. We did not have trekking poles and microspikes then, and wore our crampons much less because they did not have anti-balling plates. So we tended to rely on our ice axes, which were longer then. But you have limited confidence from an ice axe in your hand when the slope below is studded with trees, rocks and logs with which you could collide before a self-arrest takes. A very experienced mountaineer died on a solo hike on the Bear Flats Trail on Baldy in January, 2004. The reports I read did not say what equipment he was carrying or using, unfortunately. I believe there was not much snow at the time, so perhaps he was relying on rubber soles alone. It happened at around 9k, but the same type of accident can occur a few hundred yards from a parking lot.
When I cross the Traverse, I am a very slow, careful guy, even with limited snow and a pair of trekking poles in my hands. So slow I don't like to see people behind me, for fear of causing a traffic jam. I have not used my microspikes yet, but they are there in my pack. I have seen other people on the trail under the same conditions, without trekking poles or microspikes. Some seem confident, but I've also seen someone crossing the Traverse ahead of me with only a tree branch in his hand. He was clearly scared, and I thought he had good reason to be.
In short, I think snow-covered Southern California trails can be dangerous. Technical climbing can be safer than walking across a patch of icy snow on a Southern California trail relying on rubber soles alone.