by Alchad » Sun Sep 23, 2018 6:53 am
Hi, Just by way of an introduction, I'm not a hiker and originally happened on to the search for Bill via the Otherhand.org website when Googling for info on a completely different subject. However as often happens - at least to me anyway - I got sidetracked into reading the search and rescue blogs, and after digging deeper and doing more online research, ended up here. I'm also a Brit by the way which is probably irrelevant but I'll just mention it anyway.
I found the story of Bills disappearance fascinating because it has aspects which make it more of a mystery movie rather than a conventional missing person case. I also have to say how incredibly impressed I was by the dedication and time both "Otherhand" and a lot of you on this forum have put into trying to find him, really hope your efforts are rewarded one day and his family and friends can discover what happened.
However, after reading through the various blogs and all the posts on this particular thread, I've a few comments/observations which I just wanted to offer up.
Firstly, the one thing I find difficult to understand is the Carey Castle issue. The accepted understanding seems to be that a hike there was on Bill's itinerary, but after concern expressed by his fiancé, he apparently scrubbed it. So we have the situation that on the Thursday morning he was driving towards JTNP, in the opposite direction from Carey's Castle. On the drive he spoke to his fiancé by phone BUT, not only did he not mention he wasn't going there, rather he stlll seems to have left her with the impression that's where he was going. So much so that's the first place she told the Rangers to look when she contacted them to say he was missing. This just seems a very strange thing for Bill to do, why didn't he put her mind at ease? Odd, just very odd. It was also stated that Bill had joked that he'd bought a can of pepper spray, I'm not sure when this conversation with his fiancé had taken place - the Thursday morning? Or perhaps the previous evening? Again, to me the pepper spray is slightly odd, Googling about hiking to Carey's Castle I came across a few reviews that suggested it was a tricky hike from both a physical and navigational aspect, but not from the risk of being mugged.
The other issue which many others have mentioned concerns the apparent failure of Ranger Grayson to notice Bill's car in the Juniper Flats car park during the initial part of the search ( assuming it was there! ). As far as I am aware, no one has ever tried to contact Ex Ranger Grayson and ask him about this. I don't know if there is a record of whether he has a middle initial, but even if he didn't, or it is not known, I did a quick Google of the LA phone directory and identified 9 possible "M. Grayson's" in LA , and I'm sure with a bit of research half of these could be reduced ( too old, too young etc) to just a few possible candidates. I just wondered if anyone would be willing to approach these Mike Graysons to try and track down the right one and ask him for his version of the search. Ideally could the reporter who did the NYT story be persuaded to try a follow up piece. Just speculating the options are many - ranging from phone hung up/ door slammed in face through to absolute and utter conviction that he had driven by and there was no car there. Whatever reaction it would surely be informative??
On the same subject of the car and car park. Just to show how easy it is to construct conspiracy theories- you could easily, if you were that way inclined start to doubt Mimi Gorman's story about firstly not seeing the car on her way to Keys View, and then when she did see it, decide not to stop because she wanted privacy. It would be pretty obvious to see that there was nobody in the car and as the only reason a car would be there would be for the occupants to go hiking, the odds were that they would be miles away and she would have been able to eat her lunch in peace. Absolutely not offering this for consideration in the slightest, other than to demonstrate how things can get twisted.
Just my thoughts, thanks if you've bothered reading them.